Try a pencil in a deep, neutral brown! We like MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee because it defines but isn't harsh, so even if your lines aren't perfect it's okay. Maybelline Define-A-Line Eyeliner in Chestnut Brown is a great drugstore option, and it comes with a smudger to make blending easy as well. If you want a long-wearing, waterproof option, give Dior Waterproof Crayon Eyeliner in Intense Brown a try. And remember: avoid liquid and powder liners—they're harder to control.