The question at hand: what’s an easy way to style baby hairs? “Look at your face, look at the way the hair naturally falls around it,” says Rachel. “Follow that.” She took a glob of Eco Styler Gel and patted it on Chavi’s edges and brushed them forward with a stiff-bristled toothbrush (Rachel: “I have a collection of vintage toothbrushes from Milan and Paris”). To set the look, she sprayed Pump It Up Styling Spritz on top. The rest was brushed back into a low bun.

As for Chavi’s face, Mimi cleaned it with a pad soaked with Bioderma, and toned it with Mario Badescu lavender water. Dr. Hauschka rose cream went on top, followed by MAC Face and Body Foundation buffed with a stippling brush. She patted a taupe from MAC in the crease of Chavi’s eyes and along her cheekbones to add some definition, and then smeared just a little of Chanel’s Multi-Use Glow Stick in the center of Chavi’s lids for a little bit of “light.” Translucent powder from Laura Mercier set the whole look, and Too Faced Lip Injection was swiped on as a final step.

Farhiya got the same skincare treatment as Chavi, and after the rose cream was rubbed on, Laura Mercier’s Illuminating Primer quickly followed. Like with Chavi, Mimi buffed MAC’s Face and Body on Farhiya’s face, and she treated dark marks with a dab of Nars’ Radiant Creamy Concealer. As for her lids, MAC’s Pro Longwear in Quite Natural went on those, and lashes with coated in Chanel’s mascara in Brun. A tiny bit of Chanel’s Sheer Illuminating Fluid was Farhiya’s highlighter, and Pat McGrath’s Earth Angel, her lip gloss.

Of course the hair is the star here. Rachel section the front in a “V” shape to divide and conquer. The charms are from all over—Rachel loves a good vintage find—but you can find similar ones at your local craft store (try to hit up a few different ones so you get a good amount of variety). And then the rest was easy. Pulled back into a ponytail and teased just a little.

“Start with a middle part that goes a few inches back,” explained Rachel. Then make sure everything lays down flat with a handy mix of Eco Styler Gel and Pump it Up spray, brushed and shaped with a stiff toothbrush. Rachel wrapped the rest of the hair into a low bun. In your case, you might want to hunt for that old box of Godiva chocolates hanging around your kitchen. Now you’ve got a place to wrap that gold wire it comes with: around your bun.

Mimi kept the foundation from Chavi’s last look, but accentuated the eyes a tad more. MAC’s Indianwood was blended on her eyelids, and then Coffee was drawn along her waterline. She swiped on MAC’s Bold & Bad mascara right after. And then the same illuminator from Chanel, only this time mixed with Virgin Isles cream color from MAC, served as cheek color (a dupe, here). Flesh 6 from Pat McGrath completed the look.

The pouf is back! Only this time Rachel lowered it and worked in a side part. The same products from before were used on Farhiya’s baby hairs—Eco Styler Gel, Pump it Up, and a toothbrush—and they were sectioned to appear more “piece-y.” By the way, Rachel says that if you don’t have an extra toothbrush around, a cleaned mascara wand works just as well.

Mimi capped off this final look with an eyeliner hack. Instead of starting straight away with a sharp line, she applied MAC’s Smolder somewhat haphazardly along Farhiya’s top lash, and then shaped it into a winged line using a short, dense brush. “It’s way easier to control the line that way,” she said. And then a black liquid liner on top. Pat McGrath’s Flesh 6 on Farhiya’s lips marked the final step.